You know what I’m saying? I’m saying this is bullshit. If a sixteen year old Dean Winchester came face to face with a werewolf like that, he wouldn’t be alive. The werewolf wouldn’t grab him from the forearms. He or she would bite him and claw him till he was dead or too weak to move.
So yeah, this isn’t a werewolf. That’s just John.
Friendly reminder that Dean didn’t ever personally encounter a werewolf until Season 2, 11 years after this episode.
Depends on what you make of Sam’s essay in 1997’s events at Truman High.
After School Special
Mr. Wyatt: You know this assignment was nonfiction, right?
Sam: Yes, Mr. Wyatt
Mr. Wyatt: So, you and your family killed a werewolf last summer, huh?
Sam: *no answer*
Hearseeno 